top of page
Writer's pictureCarrie Evans

Why “Not in My Backyard” is Holding Us Back: How Community Growth Benefits Everyone


Individuals naturally act in their own best interest. This is known as “rational action theory.” This concept also extends to neighborhoods, where groups may prioritize their immediate surroundings, sometimes at the expense of larger, community-wide needs like housing and infrastructure. This “not in my backyard” (NIMBY) mentality often arises when new housing developments are proposed.  Communities may recognize the need for more housing to support growth, but prefer these projects happen elsewhere. 


A Collective Action Problem: Blocking Growth for Short-Term Gains

While many acknowledge that population growth brings higher wages, better infrastructure, and more state and federal funding, local resistance still slows new housing developments. This creates a collective action problem where individual groups prioritize their wants over the broader benefits of economic and community growth. Yet, new homebuyers are typically qualified, stable individuals, and research consistently shows that responsible growth raises property values, not diminishes them. 


The Reality: Evolving Neighborhoods and Rising Property Values

Today’s inner suburbs, once modest post-WWII communities, have often transformed into sought-after neighborhoods through natural gentrification. Over time, the next wave of “affordable” suburbs will similarly shift as demand for housing continues to rise. This transformation underscores a fact: as more areas grow, so does the potential for property values to increase.


When multiple communities adopt a NIMBY mindset, it leads to an overall shortage in housing supply, making it difficult for future generations to afford homes in the same neighborhoods. Moreover, zoning meeting discussions rarely capture the community’s true needs, as they often feature a small, vocal, and sometimes misinformed group of neighbors voicing concerns that don’t fully reflect public sentiment or data.


A Balanced View on Growth: Acknowledging Collective Benefits

This discussion isn’t about endorsing any particular governing structure; it’s about recognizing how a few voices can influence broader regional growth and prosperity. New developments, built to today’s high standards, create jobs, elevate community standards, and strengthen economic stability. Embracing well-planned growth is essential for fostering the collective good over individual interests.


Embracing YIMBY for Better, Affordable Communities

With modern advancements in stormwater management, traffic solutions, and other technologies, new developments address challenges better than ever.  

By moving beyond a “not in my backyard” mentality, we open doors to lasting growth, greater prosperity, and stronger communities.

31 views0 comments

Comments


bottom of page